Is it time to stop talking about the death of tape storage?

United Kingdom, May 25, 2022

By Neil Thurston, Chief Technologist, Logicalis UKI

Heritage technologies - mainframe, Unix and magnetic tape in particular – have long been a rich source for the ‘is x technology dead?’ debate. Technical pundits fill the web with head scratching over why they haven’t disappeared, or defences for their survival.     

Perhaps it is worth stepping back from this kind of debate, accepting that these technologies will be around until the last client switches the lights off, and focusing instead on what keeps them going, what the alternatives offer, and how this should influence investment decisions.   

This article considers tape storage in those terms. It considers what may be driving the ‘tape is dead’ hype, and attempts to put it aside to examine the objective factors organisations should consider in deciding to retain or replace tape technology.   

What’s driving the ‘Is tape dead?’ hype?  

According to a Straits Research Report, the global tape storage market was worth just under $5 billion in 2021, with a projected CAGR of 7.8% from 2022-2030.    

While the death of tape storage doesn’t appear to be imminent, it still faces the PR challenges of being a heritage technology that is nevertheless still widely used.  

Both vendors and customers would generally prefer heritage technologies to disappear as new tech appears. An IT landscape in which technologies linger adds complexity, cost and risk.  

The dizzying speed of IT development may also make us particularly intolerant of old technology. Compare aerospace, where the ‘old tech’ of aircraft like the DC-3 and Boeing 747 has been maintained and modernised well beyond their original expected operating lives.    

Articles asking ‘is tape dead?’ are perhaps therefore partly an expression of a sensible wish for a simpler world.  

It seems unlikely that tape storage could have survived so long purely because of client inertia, so it must still be delivering sufficient value for it to be worth retaining in some use cases.  

That is why it is worth moving away from the ‘is tape dead?’ debate to evaluating its features objectively against the alternatives, in the context of specific business strategies and goals.    

Image
Download our eBook

 

Evaluating tape against cloud storage  

For organisations without existing tape storage infrastructure, cloud is seen as offering a more flexible, cost-effective solution for traditional tape storage functions like back-up and archiving.    

In selecting a cloud service, it is still important to evaluate factors like total lifetime costs, access and retrieval service levels, and cross-border data hosting compliance.  

While rapid, self-service retrieval of cold data is a useful feature of many cloud services, this needs to be evaluated against how often backups are likely to be retrieved.     

Some cloud services still employ tape technology in the background. This should not be a significant consideration in itself, but it brings into play some of the factors that an organisation with in-house tape storage needs to consider.  

For organisations with existing tape storage infrastructure, functions like back-up and archiving can be run cheaply and efficiently, direct cost per Gb is much lower than for disk, more data can be stored in a smaller footprint, and the sunk investment may make the short to medium-term TCO more attractive than a cloud solution. 

Tape offers a major security advantage in that data stored on tape is naturally air-gapped from any network for most of its life.    

The main cost and risk drivers are the need for suitably skilled operations staff and effective retrieval processes, the fact that tape degrades over time, and obsolescence risks around tape drive infrastructure. The commitment of major vendors like IBM to continue to support and develop tape technology mitigates this risk.            

Cloud providers are selling object-based storage capabilities as the most effective way to store and access the rapidly growing volume of unstructured data, particularly media files.  

Object-based storage on disk is a relatively new technology. It offers the ability to find and access files rapidly, without the human or mechanical interventions needed with tape. Set against this, the basic technology for storing large media files on tape is mature, and, once the tape is loaded, accessing the file is fast and reliable. 

What next?  

There is no single correct answer when it comes to choosing between tape and cloud storage solutions. It depends on the specific business strategy, requirements and IT topography of the individual organisation rather than the fact that tape is heritage technology. Asking questions like ‘is tape dead?’ adds nothing to the discussion.      

Logicalis UKI has extensive expertise and experience in helping our clients to make the right, objective data storage decisions for their business. To find out more, and to continue the conversation, download our ebook or visit uki.logicalis.com.  

Topic

Related Insights

United Kingdom, Nov 23, 2022

Blogs

How to Continue Transforming During a Recession

With the current economic slowdown, it looks like another recession could be on the cards in 2023. This usually heralds a period of consolidation within IT and the closing of the purse strings with regards to planned investments. In previous decades this was standard practice, but now that we’re in a digital age, many businesses can’t afford to slow down their digital transformations if they want to survive.

Learn more

United Kingdom, Nov 23, 2022

Blogs

Reducing Digital Waste

Sustainability is imperative to all our futures and is directly impacted by every device we use that consumes power. This includes the on-premises and cloud infrastructures that power our digital work lives. To be as sustainable as possible we need to ensure that we are consuming the least amount of infrastructure to host our workloads and services, without impacting their availability, performance or governance.

Learn more
Advisory Services von Logicalis

, Sep 16, 2022

News

Only a third of CIO's cite cyber-risk mitigation as a performance measure

London, 21 March 2022: While 94% of CIOs acknowledged some form of serious threat over the next 12 months, only 27% listed business continuity and resilience as a top-three priority during the next 12 months and barely a third cited risk mitigation as a measure of performance. These findings come from the fourth section of the 2021 Global CIO Survey from Logicalis, a global provider of IT solutions.
Learn more

United Kingdom, Jun 23, 2022

Blogs

How to make the most of chatbots

Chatbots are all around us. Visit any eCommerce website today and the chances are it’ll instantly present you with a ‘How can I help you today?’ pop-up. The global market for intelligent virtual assistants is expected to grow at a CAGR of 28.5% from 2021 to 2028, and social media is full of amusing stories of parrots and small children wreaking havoc via Alexa.

Learn more

United Kingdom, Jun 20, 2022

Blogs

A brief guide to Business Process Management (BPM)

Effective Business Process Management (BPM) is an essential foundation for any successful business digitalisation and automation strategy. In summary, you can’t successfully automate a process unless you understand it fully, and BPM provides this understanding.

Learn more

United Kingdom, Jun 10, 2022

Blogs

Breaking down the great global data challenge

There are plenty of statistics around the staggering amount of data being created and consumed globally every day. 2.5 quintillion (million million million) bytes created daily by internet users, a 5000% increase in data interactions between 2010 and 2020, and so on.

Learn more

United Kingdom, Jun 3, 2022

Blogs

Explaining some important data management concepts and terms

Recent Logicalis UKI eBooks and articles have focused on the critical role of data in digital business, from unstructured data and the role of Information Lifecycle Management to the importance of robust, business-driven data storage strategy.

Learn more

United Kingdom, Jun 1, 2022

Blogs

How multi cloud data fabrics maximise data value

As data becomes an increasingly valuable asset, organisations have to adapt, to manage and protect their data to ensure it delivers maximum value to the business.

Learn more

United Kingdom, May 30, 2022

Blogs

Why data storage trends are about more than just technology

There are plenty of informative and valuable articles on the web about trends in data storage technology, discussing everything from reducing last byte latency to the wonders of consumption-based pricing. Data and storage are hot topics, unsurprisingly in an age where, as Mckinsey puts it, ‘“digital” and “data” have become the talk of the town.’

Learn more

United Kingdom, May 20, 2022

Blogs

How to avoid the pitfalls of ‘good enough’ IT

In challenging economic times, organisations naturally look to cut back or defer non-essential investment. IT spend has traditionally been one of the areas businesses look to first when the need arises to cut budgets or delay projects, sometimes creating a ‘good enough IT’ mindset, where any IT asset that is doing the job reasonably effectively today is maintained beyond the last responsible moment for replacement.

Learn more

United Kingdom, May 16, 2022

Blogs

Should we stop being ageist about Unix?

"Unix is dead, long live Unix" – a headline that is still as topical today as it was in 2009, when a blog with that title was published to mark Unix’s 40th birthday.

Learn more

United Kingdom, May 13, 2022

Blogs

Where next for Virtualisation?

In its broadest sense, virtualisation can be seen as the progressive freeing up of any computing function – compute, storage, network – from the constraints of its physical infrastructure. So far, virtualisation has been a continuous evolution, from the first virtual machines (VMs) to the world of hybrid cloud, and there is no sign yet of this evolution losing momentum.

Learn more

United Kingdom, Feb 21, 2022

News

The Changing Threat Landscape

The range and impact of Information Security (IS) threats has grown and changed continually over the last 40 years or more, along with the motivations and drivers for such attacks. From when the Morris Worm launched the first, apparently inadvertent, distributed denial-of-service (DDoS) attack on the internet, the realm of cybercrime has expanded from hackers often driven by little more than curiosity, to organised crime and state sponsorship.
Learn more